Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Richard B (Norfolk, UK)'s avatar

I think I see where you are coming from. You are right to advocate being less judgmental. We can never look into the minds and lives of complete strangers; yet social media postings overflow with ill-informed and unpleasant comments to and about anyone who dares to stick their head above the parapet.

In the circumstances you describe I agree up to a point. As you say we are more alike than different. No matter how rich people are, they cannot avoid the emotions we all experience: love, hate, joy, sadness and the rest. The richest man or woman in the world still has to fight the same viruses as we do, has to eat to stay alive and also has to excrete what has been digested (along with universal flatulence!)

Yet I cannot help thinking that there is something ultimately skewed about having such extreme wealth concentrated into the hands of one person. Take Mukesh Ambani. As you say he is Asia’s richest man and is worth about $83.6 billion. That is eighty three thousand million dollars (or $83,000,000,000.00).

He is currently aged 67 (10 years younger than I am, but I am maxed out on my credit cards and have a debit bank balance but I am happy with my lot). Let’s assume he lives to be 100. He will therefore have around 33 years of life left.

That is about 12,045 days or 289,080 hours. If he starts to give away or spend his fortune now at the rate of a million dollars every 3 hours he will not have disposed of it all by the time of his death - and he will not be able to take with hm what remains. I use that analogy to illustrate what an absurdly large amount of money he possesses. No one, but no one, needs that level of wealth, and I don’t think one can soften it by pointing out the number of people who earned money from being paid to put on his sumptuous wedding celebration, or that the family are top charitable donors.

I don’t judge but nonetheless I feel uneasy. Others wiser than I am advocate a very good reason for moderating extremes of wealth. See for instance this recent paper in Nature: “Why the world cannot afford the rich” https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-024-00723-3. The two authors have developed their theme in 2 excellent books.

So that’s my non-judgmental (honestly) take on this situation. Maybe if they had given me an invitation and paid my airfare I might have thought differently - just kidding!

Expand full comment
Shalini gupta's avatar

Totally agree who we r to judge others … if we try to find the positive in this whole celebration… lot of positive outcomes as to job opportunities and economic impact of the spending . However at the same time negative impacts in terms of pressure on others and what not. It’s not for us to judge … love the reasoning for not judging .

Expand full comment
13 more comments...

No posts